1. Home
  2. Techniques
  3. ICS
  4. Module Firmware

Module Firmware

Adversaries may install malicious or vulnerable firmware onto modular hardware devices. Control system devices often contain modular hardware devices. These devices may have their own set of firmware that is separate from the firmware of the main control system equipment.

This technique is similar to System Firmware, but is conducted on other system components that may not have the same capabilities or level of integrity checking. Although it results in a device re-image, malicious device firmware may provide persistent access to remaining devices. [1]

An easy point of access for an adversary is the Ethernet card, which may have its own CPU, RAM, and operating system. The adversary may attack and likely exploit the computer on an Ethernet card. Exploitation of the Ethernet card computer may enable the adversary to accomplish additional attacks, such as the following: [1]

  • Delayed Attack - The adversary may stage an attack in advance and choose when to launch it, such as at a particularly damaging time.
  • Brick the Ethernet Card - Malicious firmware may be programmed to result in an Ethernet card failure, requiring a factory return.
  • Random Attack or Failure - The adversary may load malicious firmware onto multiple field devices. Execution of an attack and the time it occurs is generated by a pseudo-random number generator.
  • A Field Device Worm - The adversary may choose to identify all field devices of the same model, with the end goal of performing a device-wide compromise.
  • Attack Other Cards on the Field Device - Although it is not the most important module in a field device, the Ethernet card is most accessible to the adversary and malware. Compromise of the Ethernet card may provide a more direct route to compromising other modules, such as the CPU module.
ID: T0839
Sub-techniques:  No sub-techniques
ⓘ
Platforms: None
Version: 1.1
Created: 21 May 2020
Last Modified: 13 October 2023
Version Permalink

Targeted Assets

ID Asset
A0003 Programmable Logic Controller (PLC)
A0010 Safety Controller

Mitigations

ID Mitigation Description
M0801 Access Management

All devices or systems changes, including all administrative functions, should require authentication. Consider using access management technologies to enforce authorization on all management interface access attempts, especially when the device does not inherently provide strong authentication and authorization functions.
M0947 Audit

Perform integrity checks of firmware before uploading it on a device. Utilize cryptographic hashes to verify the firmware has not been tampered with by comparing it to a trusted hash of the firmware. This could be from trusted data sources (e.g., vendor site) or through a third-party verification service.
M0946 Boot Integrity

Check the integrity of the existing BIOS or EFI to determine if it is vulnerable to modification. Use Trusted Platform Module technology. [2] Move system's root of trust to hardware to prevent tampering with the SPI flash memory. [3] Technologies such as Intel Boot Guard can assist with this. [4]
M0945 Code Signing

Devices should verify that firmware has been properly signed by the vendor before allowing installation.
M0802 Communication Authenticity

Protocols used for device management should authenticate all network messages to prevent unauthorized system changes.
M0808 Encrypt Network Traffic

The encryption of firmware should be considered to prevent adversaries from identifying possible vulnerabilities within the firmware.
M0941 Encrypt Sensitive Information

The encryption of firmware should be considered to prevent adversaries from identifying possible vulnerabilities within the firmware.
M0937 Filter Network Traffic

Filter for protocols and payloads associated with firmware activation or updating activity.
M0804 Human User Authentication

Devices that allow remote management of firmware should require authentication before allowing any changes. The authentication mechanisms should also support Account Use Policies, Password Policies, and User Account Management.
M0807 Network Allowlists

Use host-based allowlists to prevent devices from accepting connections from unauthorized systems. For example, allowlists can be used to ensure devices can only connect with master stations or known management/engineering workstations. [5]
M0930 Network Segmentation

Segment operational network and systems to restrict access to critical system functions to predetermined management systems. [5]
M0813 Software Process and Device Authentication

Authenticate connections fromsoftware and devices to prevent unauthorized systems from accessing protected management functions.

Detection

ID Data Source Data Component Detects
DS0015 Application Log Application Log Content

Monitor device application logs for firmware changes, although not all devices will produce such logs.
DS0001 Firmware Firmware Modification

Monitor firmware for unexpected changes. Asset management systems should be consulted to understand known-good firmware versions. Dump and inspect BIOS images on vulnerable systems and compare against known good images.[6] Analyze differences to determine if malicious changes have occurred. Log attempts to read/write to BIOS and compare against known patching behavior. Likewise, EFI modules can be collected and compared against a known-clean list of EFI executable binaries to detect potentially malicious modules. The CHIPSEC framework can be used for analysis to determine if firmware modifications have been performed.[7] [8] [9]
DS0029 Network Traffic Network Traffic Content

Monitor ICS management protocols / file transfer protocols for protocol functions related to firmware changes.
DS0040 Operational Databases Device Alarm

Monitor for firmware changes which may be observable via operational alarms from devices.

References

  1. Daniel Peck, Dale Peterson 2009, January 28 Leveraging Ethernet Card Vulnerabilities in Field Devices Retrieved. 2017/12/19
  2. N/A Trusted Platform Module (TPM) Summary Retrieved. 2020/09/25
  3. ESET Research Whitepapers 2018, September LOJAX First UEFI rootkit found in the wild, courtesy of the Sednit group Retrieved. 2020/09/25
  4. Intel ESET Research Whitepapers 2018, September LOJAX First UEFI rootkit found in the wild, courtesy of the Sednit group Retrieved. 2020/09/25 Intel Hardware-based Security Technologies for Intelligent Retail Devices Retrieved. 2020/09/25
  5. Department of Homeland Security 2016, September Retrieved. 2020/09/25
  1. Butterworth, J. (2013, July 30). Copernicus: Question Your Assumptions about BIOS Security. Retrieved December 11, 2015.
  2. Beek, C., Samani, R. (2017, March 8). CHIPSEC Support Against Vault 7 Disclosure Scanning. Retrieved March 13, 2017.
  3. Intel. (2017, March 18). CHIPSEC Platform Security Assessment Framework. Retrieved March 20, 2017.
  4. Intel Security. (2005, July 16). HackingTeam's UEFI Rootkit Details. Retrieved March 20, 2017.